International mediators are currently finalizing a new cease-fire proposal to bridge the gaps between Israel and Hamas, according to U.S. and regional officials. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu remains adamant that he will not relinquish control of Gaza’s border with Egypt, which remains a critical stumbling point for reaching a deal. While Hamas officials have made new demands in the negotiations and refused to participate directly in the most recent round of talks, asserting that neither Israel nor the U.S. has demonstrated genuine commitment to reaching an acceptable agreement. Nevertheless, they have maintained communication with Qatari and Egyptian mediators.
Qatar and Egypt have jointly drafted a series of revisions, which are now under discussion with U.S. officials. David Barnea, the director of Israel’s intelligence service Mossad, was in Doha, Qatar, on Monday to engage in discussions related to the proposed document.
Though international pressure is mounting on Israel to accept a ceasefire agreement, it remains highly unlikely that any ceasefire between Israel and Hamas will be reached before next year.
Key Points of Contention
- Prisoner Release: Both sides are still negotiating exactly how many hostages would be released by Hamas in exchange for Palestinian prisoners held by Israel. According to U.S. officials, Hamas has never agreed to Israeli terms on this issue. In recent weeks, political pressure has increased within Israel to reach an agreement that frees Israeli hostages held by Hamas. This culminated in mass protests throughout Israel following the discovery of six executed hostages in Gaza. It is currently estimated that Hamas holds 60 hostages that are still alive along with the bodies of 35 hostages. In recent days, Hamas negotiators have introduced a new demand that was not part of previous discussions. Hamas is now making demands on which prisoners would be released by Israel in a potential ceasefire agreement.
- IDF Troop Withdrawal: The other significant dispute pertains to Israel’s withdrawal of troops from the Philadelphi corridor—a narrow strip of Gaza along the Egyptian border. Initially, Israel had agreed to a phased withdrawal plan, but Netanyahu disrupted that arrangement last week. Netanyahu has maintained his longstanding position that Israel retain control of the Philadelphi Corridor to prevent Hamas from rearming through cross-border smuggling. Hamas has demanded a total Israeli withdrawal from Gaza. Egypt has also raised objections to an indefinite Israeli military presence near its border in the Philadelphi Corridor.
The Biden Administration has made brokering a ceasefire agreement between Israel and Hamas a core part of Biden’s remaining time in office. However, despite significant efforts and involvement from the White House, the situation is no closer to a ceasefire than it was months ago.
There is tension between Israel and the U.S. on Iran policy. The Biden administration’s efforts to negotiate a nuclear deal with Tehran have backfired and Iran is on the threshold of a nuclear weapon. Iran continues its support to Hamas and Hezbollah which has opened another front in Israel’s north.
Some analysts have observed that Hamas’ shifting demands during talks demonstrate the terror group is not incentivized to reach an agreement and has calculated that international pressure will continue to mount on Israel to accept less than desirable terms. Likewise, Israel has faced significant headwinds and constraints from the Biden Administration and Netanyahu likely believes that if Donald Trump is elected President, Israel will have more American support. Netanyahu probably believes that Vice President Harris will try to constrain Israel’s efforts while restoring nuclear negotiations with concessions to Iran.
AGS will continue to monitor the situation and provide updates on any significant developments.
To stay up to date on what AGS is doing, follow us on LinkedIn